How to Start a Book Club

How to Start a Book Club: Step-by-Step

1. 1

   Define your reading focus and meeting format

   Choose a focus: literary fiction, genre fiction (mystery, sci-fi, romance), nonfiction, or an eclectic mix. Decide on meeting format: in-person rotating homes, at a library/coffee shop, virtual via Zoom, or hybrid. A clear identity attracts the right members.
2. 2

   Recruit founding members

   Start with 6–12 members — small enough for real conversation, large enough to continue when people miss meetings. Invite friends directly, post on Nextdoor or Facebook groups, or partner with a local library or bookstore.
3. 3

   Establish ground rules and expectations

   Agree on: How are books selected? What happens if someone hasn't finished? What is the attendance expectation? Can members bring guests? How are meeting locations decided? These conversations up front prevent friction later.
4. 4

   Choose a book selection method

   Common methods: rotating nominations (each member nominates a book and the group votes), a designated selector rotates through members, or themed reading lists. The most democratic methods have the highest group buy-in.
5. 5

   Set a regular meeting schedule

   Monthly meetings are most common and sustainable. Pick a consistent day and time (e.g., first Tuesday at 7pm) so members can plan around it. Irregular scheduling is the #1 predictor of book club failure.
6. 6

   For formal clubs: draft simple bylaws and get an EIN

   If your club collects dues, manages a club library, or hosts public events, draft a simple 1–2 page constitution. Obtain a free EIN and open a club bank account to keep finances organized.
7. 7

   Set up a communication and management tool

   Even informal clubs benefit from a shared platform for announcements, book selections, and RSVPs. GatherGrove or a simple group chat handles this for small clubs; larger clubs benefit from proper membership management software.
8. 8

   Host your first meeting

   For the first meeting, choose a widely loved, accessible book. Focus on relationship-building as much as discussion. The quality of the first experience heavily influences whether people return.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• ✗No clear book-selection process, leading to disputes and member attrition
• ✗No attendance norms — host burden when many members show up without reading
• ✗Growing too large too fast (groups over 15 lose the intimate discussion quality)
• ✗No succession plan when a founding member moves or leaves

Software Built for Your Club Type

Related Resources